“ We stopped in yesterday for a late lunch and we're so glad we did! Tip: many businesses and eateries in Winslow are closed on Monday; not Cafe Hitchcock. Service was warm, friendly and quick. The food is unique even if the item has a non unique name. We ordered non unique Ham and Cheese Sandwich and Pastrami with an Irish coffee to take the chill from outdoors off. The sandwiches were amazing my pastrami was on real Jewish rye piled high with lean tasty pastrami just enough sauerkraut to add zing and not soak the rye bread. A pickle or two and some fancy fantastic sauce. I have never had better or even as good. Jeanie raved about her ham and cheese on focaccia. Both sandwiches come with delicious potato chips we assume made in-house. Ambience is noisy cafe with lots of locals chatting! What a perfect setting for a perfect cafe meal. ”

“ This place was everything--great service and great food! We took the ferry from Seattle to Bainbridge, and this was our first stop. We came in to get a snack and drinks. The bartender was great; it's so cute and quaint in this café. This area give me small town vides which I love. ”

“ We decided to end our night at a nearby bar-- just so happened that we happened upon Cafe Hitchcock on a drag night. STOKED seeing local queens, I've heard amazing things about how diverse the Seattle drag scene is. Also, the drinks here are fire~~~ We walked in on a Saturday evening and somehow found a table for our group of 4. Pretty lively + great music. Vibe is divey. Pleasantly surprised by the table service-- bartender took our order minutes after us settling in. WINSLOW'S WAY: Ok this is juice. Love it. I could drink this all day-- the most refreshing, minty, fruity cocktail ever. We got to catch Hannah Mia Joint St. James and Clara Voyance performing a few numbers. The girls killlllled it. Love to support queer-friendly biz. Will have to be back for their brunch and actual food sometime! ”

“ Absolutely loved this cozy spot on Bainbridge Island! The tomato soup was rich and comforting, perfect for the partly cloudy day. The café salad was fresh and crisp with tomato soup, a great light option. In addition, we had the Chi-Town sandwich--house-roasted beef with melted provolone, giardiniera, and aioli. Our waitress was spot on, on explaining flavors and textures, and you could taste the quality in every bite. Highly recommend stopping by if you're in the area! Not depicted - the Bloody Mary - pretty good! I give it a solid 8.5/10 (wasn't a fan of the pickled cauliflower, but overall the mix and presentation was great!) Pro tip: your waiter/waitress has the ability to take your coffee order for the cafe attached. ”

“ Chicken noodle soup was bomb! Exactly what I needed that day when I just wanted something light but delicious. It was so flavorful-robust and peppery and it had plenty of chicken and noodles. The salad was a great complement to the soup. My companion had a breakfast sandwich which he enjoyed. While there was a long wait for tables because of the ferry, we were able to sit at the bar for quicker seating. Nathan was a great host-gave great service and recommendations. ”

“ Seeing the low star reviews made no sense with my experience. Ordered the pb&j smoothie and it was brought out very quickly. Gentleman next to me did say it took between 15-20 mins to get his food but in my point of view that's a very standard wait time. Ambiance is very relaxing with soft rock and roll music, staff is polite and kind. My friends and I find everything here reasonably priced. Great place to relax while waiting for the main food at Ba Sa ”

“ We've been to Bainbridge a few times by now. Tried this spot the last time we went. They have a really delicious grilled cheese that they make using focaccia and some green sauce. We also got a double baked hazelnut croissant and some lavender coffee :) My husband got a grilled sandwich with chips, was really good. They have a huge indoor seating. We sat outside with our dog :) it's sort of covered and small (2 tables I think) Good for sunshine or a light drizzle. They were quite busy and managed a good service with that. While we just wanted to grab a bite, they had some nice options for lunch/ dinner. ”

“ Cafe Hitchcock was chosen for its brunch menu and good drinks. The atmosphere is lively and fun. You feel welcome here in Bainbridge. The bar tenders and servers are friendly and entertaining. They make some awesome drinks at the bar. It's not cheap but it is high quality. They also have bottomless mimosas for $20. The food menu is small but quality. The breakfast sandwich for $13 includes thick bacon and a large egg, and the other menu items my friends ordered were pleasantly surprised with the taste. Everything is fresh for sure. I will definitely return for food and beverages. They even knew it was my birthday somehow. ”